2002 (with a win in the tournament final against Newark Academy), 2004 (vs. Newark Academy), 2006 (vs. Eastern Christian High School) and 2008 (vs. Eastern Christian High School) and was Non-Public A co-champion in 2017 (with Immaculate Heart Academy). The program's five state titles are tied for tenth-most in the state. The girls' soccer team won the 2003 South Parochial B title by edging Holy Spirit High School 2–1 The team repeated for the South B state championship in 2004 with a 5–0 win over Holy Spirit. The team won the 2006 South B title with a 1–0 win vs. Gloucester Catholic High School. In 2007, the team won the South B state sectional championship with a 2–0 win over Holy Cross High School in the tournament final. In 2017 the team was Non-Public A co-champs tying 1–1 after double overtime with Immaculate Heart Academy in the finals. The ice hockey team won the Handchen Cup in 2004 and 2005. The girls field hockey team won the 2006 Central Jersey Group I state tournament with a 2–1 win over New Egypt High School. The boys' swimming team won the 2007 Non-Public Group B championship with a 98–72 win over Pingry School. In 2007, the boys' freshmen crew team was the first crew team to win the New Jersey state championships in Bishop Eustace School history. In 2007, 2008, and 2009, the Bishop Eustace Varsity Girls Crew won first place in the Stotesbury Cup Regatta's Varsity 8 category. In 2007, the Varsity 8 competed in the Henley Women's Regatta in England. In 2010, the Bishop Eustace Varsity 8 Boys Crew Team won the New Jersey Scholastic Championships. The boys track team won the indoor track championship in Non-Public B in 2010 (as co-champion) and 2015–2019. The program is tied for tenth in state titles, with six. Notable alumni Brian Clarhaut (born 1986), soccer coach who coaches Nyköpings BIS in the Swedish Division 1. Zac Gallen (born 1995), pitcher for the Arizona Diamondbacks. Kelli James (born 1970), United States Olympian field hockey striker who earned a total number of 144 caps for the women's national field hockey team. Sara Keane (born 1991), footballer who played as goalkeeper for FC Kansas City. Billy Lange (born 1972), former head men's basketball coach at the United States Naval Academy who started his coaching career at Bishop Eustace in 1995–96. Bill Melchionni (born 1944) 76ers and