(Melbourne Theatre Company) | Best Female Actor in a Play | | rowspan="3"| |- | Alison Whyte – Don's Party (Melbourne Theatre Company and Sydney Theatre Company) | Best Female Actor in a Supporting Role in a Play | |- | Travis McMahon – Don's Party (Melbourne Theatre Company and Sydney Theatre Company) | Best Male Actor in a Supporting Role in a Play | |- | rowspan="2"| 2009 |Peter Evans – Blackbird (Melbourne Theatre Company) | Best Direction of a Play | | rowspan="2"| |- | Grant Piro – Realism (Melbourne Theatre Company) | Best Male Actor in a Supporting Role in a Play | |- | rowspan="5"| 2010 | Richard III (Melbourne Theatre Company) | rowspan="2"| Best Play | | rowspan="5"| |- | August: Osage County (Melbourne Theatre Company) | |- | Jane Menelaus – August: Osage County (Melbourne Theatre Company) | rowspan="2"| Best Female in a Play | |- | Robyn Nevin – August: Osage County (Melbourne Theatre Company) | |- | The Drowsy Chaperone| Best Musical | |- | rowspan="5"| 2012 | The Importance of Being Earnest (Melbourne Theatre Company) | Best Play | | rowspan="5"| |- |Simon Phillips – Songs for Nobodies (Melbourne Theatre Company in association with Duet) | Best Direction of a Play | |- |Colin Friels – Red (Melbourne Theatre Company) | Best Male Actor in a Play | |- |Bob Hornery – The Importance of Being Earnest (Melbourne Theatre Company) | rowspan="2"| Best Male Actor in a Supporting Role in a Play | |- |Patrick Brammall – Clybourne Park (Melbourne Theatre Company) | |- | rowspan="2"| 2013 |Alison Bell – Constellations (Melbourne Theatre Company) | Best Female Actor in a Play | | rowspan="2"| |- | Valerie Bader – Australia Day (Sydney Theatre Company and Melbourne Theatre Company) | Best Female Actor in a Supporting Role in a Play | |- | rowspan="2"| 2014 |Zahra Newman – The Mountaintop (Melbourne Theatre Company) | Best Female Actor in a Play | | rowspan="2"| |- | Tom Budge – The Beast (Melbourne Theatre Company) | Best Male Actor in a Supporting Role in a Play | |- | rowspan="3"| 2015 | Clare Watson – What Rhymes with Cars and Girls (Melbourne Theatre Company) | Best Direction of a Play | | rowspan="3"| |- | Julie Forsyth – Endgame (Melbourne Theatre Company) | Best Female Actor in a Supporting Role in a Play |