co-production Teddy Riley – songwriting Aaron Hall – songwriting Timmy Gatling – songwriting Gene Griffin – songwriting Nicki Richards – backing vocals Ronnie King – Moog Michael Scheshingen – mixer Ashburn Bernie Miller – engineer Brian Nolen – MIDI editor Jeff Burns – assistant engineer Pete Karem – assistant engineer Bod Ludwig – mastering Charts Release history References Further reading 2000 singles Mariah Carey songs Music videos directed by Sanaa Hamri Snoop Dogg songs Songs written by Mariah Carey Songs written by Snoop Dogg Songs written by Teddy Riley Songs written by Aaron Hall (singer) 1999 songs Columbia Records singles Sony Music singles Songs about heartache Songs written by Timmy Gatling