transformed into a submarine with visuals from the film on its London–Paris service. Music journalist Rob Chapman writes that "Yellow Submarine" inaugurated a trend for nursery rhyme-like songs during the psychedelic era, peaking in late 1967 with UK top-ten singles for Keith West, Traffic and Simon Dupree and the Big Sound. Nicholas Schaffner recognised the track as an exception within the music-industry phenomenon of novelty songs, which were traditionally gimmicky recordings by one-hit wonders, since the Beatles were the most popular stars of the era and achieved one of the most commercially successful novelty hits of all time. By the early 2000s, according to music journalist Charles Shaar Murray, "Yellow Submarine" was a "perennial children's favourite". Rolling Stones editors describe it as "the gateway drug that turns little children into Beatle fans". The tune of the song has been used in protests and demonstrations in Britain and America, with the lyrics changed to "We all live in a fascist regime". It was adopted in this way by protesters in New York City during George Bush's inauguration as US president in January 2005; by anti-G8 protesters in Scotland in July the same year; by anti-monarchist demonstrators in London on the day of Prince William and Kate Middleton's wedding in April 2011; and by Londoners protesting the result of the UK general election in May 2015. Starr reprised the song's nautical and escapist themes in his 1969 composition "Octopus's Garden", his second and last song recorded by the Beatles. "Yellow Submarine" has continued to be one of his signature songs during his post-Beatles solo career. He has regularly included it in his concert set lists when touring with the All Starr Band. The first of several live versions appears on the 1992 album Ringo Starr and His All Starr Band Volume 2: Live from Montreux. For McCartney, "Yellow Submarine" inaugurated a strand of his writing that became highly popular among generations of children yet was also open to mockery by his detractors. Later examples of his children's songs include "All Together Now" from Yellow Submarine; Wings' "Mary Had a Little Lamb", based on the nursery rhyme of that title; and "We All Stand Together", from McCartney's 1984 animated short film Rupert and the Frog Song. The Beatles' recording was included on compilation albums such as 1962–1966 and 1. In 1986, "Yellow Submarine" / "Eleanor Rigby" was reissued in the UK as part