Providence On October 24, 2011, the band released their fourth album Divine Providence. Produced by Cosmic Thug production duo Adam Landry and Justin Collins, the album was the first to feature the current and definitive lineup of the band and displayed a louder and rawer sound than previous releases, with the band aiming to capture "the raw and spontaneous kerosene blaze" of their live show, admitting that they "just kind of got sick of hearing the words indie-folk and shit like that." The album saw the band compared to The Kinks, The Rolling Stones and The Replacements. A secret track was included in the form of "Mr Cigarette" written by The Replacements' Paul Westerberg. Although the band were told by his manager that Westerberg had written the song especially for the band, it had previously been released as part of a 30-minute download Grandpaboy's Last Stand the previous year. The album was also the first to feature songs written and sung by other members, "Walkin Out the Door" and "Now It's Your Turn" by O'Neil and "Clownin Around" by Dennis Ryan, a song written about and from the perspective of the serial child murderer John Wayne Gacy. The change in direction resulted in a mixed reception from some critics and fans, with McCauley simply stating that it was just the natural evolution of the band and that the previous confusion caused by the gulf between their albums and live shows was "getting kind of old." The band expected some fans to hate it, but McCauley stated that "first and foremost, it’s music and the record I wanted to make. Our live shows are really different than our records. So we wanted to get in a room and hit record, just go there". Commenting on the production, McCauley revealed that he actually liked "listening to it. I haven’t really gotten there with any previous recordings. It’s a lot more accurate as to what we enjoy listening to." The album was named after a "very blasphemous anti-Christian metal song" written by Dennis Ryan which they were going to release later as a split single with a metal band, with McCauley stating that he didn't "want to be stuck just doing one thing ever," but remains unreleased. The album was released in the UK and Europe via Loose Music, who issued the album with the band's US vinyl/digital only EP Tim as a