and was buried at Dunkeld Cathedral, where his grave can still be seen. He married twice but had no issue. Occasionally, it has been suggested that Prince Charles married Clementina Walkinshaw, and thus that Charlotte was legitimate and could legally claim to be her father's successor. However, there are no records to substantiate this claim, and the affidavit signed by Clementina on 9 March 1767 explicitly disavows the idea. Further, Charles's initial disavowal of Charlotte speaks against her legitimacy. It was generally believed that Charlotte's daughters also died without issue but Peter Pininski believed that Charlotte's daughter, Victoire Adelaide, did have issue. Pininski's 2002 book suggested that Jules-Hercule, Prince de Guéméné and Duke of Montbazon, elder brother of Ferdinand de Rohan (and aide-de-camp to Henry Stuart in 1745) recognised Charlotte's offspring as his own – thus giving her status in that tight family, and claimed that in 1793, at the outbreak of the French revolution, Victoire Adelaide de Rohan went to relatives in Poland and there met and married Paul Anthony Louis Bertrand de Nikorowicz, a Polish nobleman and son of a banker. They had a son, Antime, who was the father of Charles and a daughter, Julia-Thérèse, who married Count Leonard Pininski and became Peter Pininski's great-great-grandmother. Pininski's evidence for his thesis has been described as "often indirect, if not elliptical"; the Rohans were a large family, and it is easy to confuse its many members. A former chairman of the Royal Stuart Society, however, stated that Pininski's evidence seemed "genuine", and peerage editor Hugh Massingberd described it as "painstakingly researched ... proof to surely the most sceptical pedant's satisfaction". Pininski's hypothesis has, however, since been challenged by genealogist Marie-Louise Backhurst in two articles in 2013 and 2021. Backhurst provides evidence that Charlotte's second daughter, who was always called Victoire Adelaide, was married firstly at St Roch, Paris, in November 1804 to a military doctor in the service of Napoleon, Pierre Joseph Marie de St Ursin. The marriage record has Victoire Adelaide Roehenstart, daughter of Maximilien and his wife Clementine Ruthven, the same parental record as her brother Charles. By St Ursin she was the mother of Theodore Marie de St Ursin, who was born in Paris on 29 June 1809 and who was still resident in Paris in 1832 and perhaps later, he having entered the seminary of St Sulpice at Issy in 1828 and been ordained a