|| Happ (0–1) || — || 43,359 || 1–1 |- bgcolor=#ffbbbb | 3 || October 15 || Astros || Yankee Stadium || 1–4 || Cole (1–0) || Severino (0–1) || Osuna (1) || 48,998 || 1–2 |- bgcolor=#bbbbbb | — || October 16 || Astros || colspan=7| Postponed (Inclement Weather, makeup date on October 17) |- bgcolor=#ffbbbb | 4 || October 17 || Astros || Yankee Stadium || 3–8 || Pressly (1–0) || Tanaka (1–1) || — || 49,067 || 1–3 |- bgcolor=#ccffcc | 5 || October 18 || Astros || Yankee Stadium || 4–1 || Paxton (1−0) || Verlander (0−1) || Chapman (1) || 48,483 || 2–3 |- bgcolor=#ffbbbb | 6 || October 19 || @ Astros || Minute Maid Park || 4–6 || Osuna (1–0) || Chapman (0–1) || — || 43,357 || 2–4 |- Postseason rosters | style="text-align:left" | Pitchers: 0 Adam Ottavino 19 Masahiro Tanaka 34 J. A. Happ 40 Luis Severino 43 Jonathan Loáisiga 48 Tommy Kahnle 53 Zack Britton 54 Aroldis Chapman 57 Chad Green 65 James Paxton 70 Tyler Lyons 85 Luis Cessa Catchers: 24 Gary Sánchez 28 Austin Romine Infielders: 14 Tyler Wade 18 Didi Gregorius 25 Gleyber Torres 26 DJ LeMahieu 29 Gio Urshela 45 Luke Voit Outfielders: 11 Brett Gardner 27 Giancarlo Stanton 38 Cameron Maybin 99 Aaron Judge Designated hitters: 30 Edwin Encarnación |- valign="top" | style="text-align:left" | Pitchers: 0 Adam Ottavino 19 Masahiro Tanaka 34 J. A. Happ 40 Luis Severino 43 Jonathan Loáisiga 48 Tommy Kahnle 52 CC Sabathia 53 Zack Britton 54 Aroldis Chapman 57 Chad Green 61 Ben Heller 65 James Paxton 70 Tyler Lyons 85 Luis Cessa Catchers: 24 Gary Sánchez 28 Austin Romine Infielders: 18 Didi Gregorius 25 Gleyber Torres 26 DJ LeMahieu 29 Gio Urshela Outfielders: 11 Brett Gardner 27 Giancarlo Stanton 31 Aaron Hicks 38 Cameron Maybin 99 Aaron Judge Designated hitters: 30 Edwin Encarnación |- valign="top" Honors All-Stars The team delegates for the 2019 All-Star Game were DJ LeMahieu, Gary Sanchez, Gleyber Torres, Masahiro Tanaka and Aroldis Chapman, which represented the team as part of the winning American League team that won in Cleveland 4–3 against the National League. Tanaka and Chapman made history as they were for the first time since the save was officially adopted in the late 60s as the first ever Yankees to get the All-Star Game win and save, respectively (last time this happened was