April 30 || @ Braves || 4–3 || Paddack (2–1) || Teherán (2–4) || Yates (14) || 18,626 || 17–13 || W1 |- |-style=background:#fbb;" ||31|| May 1 || @ Braves || 1–5 || Fried (4–1) || Quantrill (0–1) || — || 20,394 || 17–14 || L1 |-style=background:#bfb;" ||32|| May 2 || @ Braves || 11–2 || Strahm (1–2) || Foltynewicz (0–1) || — || 23,746 || 18–14 || W1 |-style=background:#fbb;" ||33|| May 3 || Dodgers || 3–4 || Alexander (2–1) || Yates (0–1) || Jansen (11) || 44,425 || 18–15 || L1 |-style=background:#fbb;" ||34|| May 4 || Dodgers || 6–7 || Stripling (2–2) || Yates (0–2) || Jansen (12) || 44,558 || 18–16 || L2 |-style=background:#bfb;" ||35|| May 5 || Dodgers || 8–5 || Warren (2–0) || Jansen (2–1) || — || 44,473 || 19–16 || W1 |-style=background:#bfb;" ||36|| May 6 || Mets || 4–0 || Paddack (3–1) || deGrom (2–4) || Stammen (1) || 20,176 || 20–16 || W2 |-style=background:#fbb;" ||37|| May 7 || Mets || 6–7 || Lugo (2–0) || Warren (2–1) || Díaz (9) || 23,129 || 20–17 || L1 |-style=background:#bfb;" ||38|| May 8 || Mets || 3–2 || Reyes (2–0) || Bashlor (0–1) || Yates (15) || 21,952 || 21–17 || W1 |-style=background:#fbb;" ||39|| May 10 || @ Rockies || 2–12 || Márquez (4–2) || Lauer (2–4) || — || 27,594 || 21–18 || L1 |-style=background:#bfb;" ||40|| May 11 || @ Rockies || 4–3 || Stammen (4–1) || Davis (1–1) || Yates (16) || 37,118 || 22–18 || W1 |-style=background:#fbb;" ||41|| May 12 || @ Rockies || 7–10 || Senzatela (3–2) || Margevicius (2–4) || — || 40,234 || 22–19 || L1 |-style=background:#fbb;" ||42|| May 14 || @ Dodgers || 3–6 || Kershaw (3–0) || Paddack (3–2) || Jansen (13) || 46,460 || 22–20 || L2 |-style=background:#fbb;" ||43|| May 15 || @ Dodgers || 0–2 || Maeda (5–2) || Strahm (1–3) || Jansen (14) || 41,671 || 22–21 || L3 |-style=background:#bfb;" ||44|| May 16 || Pirates || 4–3 || Warren (3–1) || Rodríguez (0–3) || Yates (17) || 20,877 || 23–21 || W1 |-style=background:#fbb;" ||45|| May 17 || Pirates || 3–5 || Lyles (4–1) || Lucchesi (3–3) || — || 28,913 || 23–22 || L1 |-style=background:#fbb ||46|| May 18 || Pirates || 2–7 || Brault (1–1) || Margevicius (2–5) || — || 39,856 || 23–23 || L2 |-style=background:#fbb ||47|| May 19 || Pirates || 4–6 ||