|| Kelly (10–14) || Lugo (5) || Citi Field|| 21,337 || 73–70 |-style=background:#bfb |144|| September 10||Diamondbacks || 3–2 || Wheeler (11–7) || Gallen (3–5) || Wilson (2) || Citi Field|| 20,843 || 74–70 |-style=background:#bfb |145|| September 11||Diamondbacks || 9–0 || Matz (10–8) || Ray (12–8) || — || Citi Field|| 21,841 || 75–70 |-style=background:#bfb |146|| September 12||Diamondbacks || 11–1 || Stroman (8–13) || Young (7–4) || — || Citi Field|| 21,856 || 76–70 |-style=background:#fbb |147|| September 13||Dodgers || 2–9 || Kershaw (14–5) || Syndergaard (10–8) || — || Citi Field|| 36,097 || 76–71 |-style=background:#bfb |148|| September 14||Dodgers || 3–0 || Lugo (6–3) || Kelly (5–4) || Wilson (3) || Citi Field|| 39,264 || 77–71 |-style=background:#fbb |149|| September 15||Dodgers || 2–3 || Jansen (5–3) || Lugo (6–4) || Maeda (2) || Citi Field|| 31,521 || 77–72 |-style=background:#fbb |150|| September 16||@ Rockies || 4–9 || Senzatela (10–10) || Matz (10–9) || — || Coors Field || 28,505 || 77–73 |-style=background:#bfb |151|| September 17||@ Rockies || 6–1 || Stroman (9–13) || Melville (2–3) || — || Coors Field || 33,118 || 78–73 |-style=background:#bfb |152|| September 18||@ Rockies || 7–4 || Lugo (7–4) || Díaz (5–4) || — || Coors Field || 30,174 || 79–73 |-style=background:#bfb |153|| September 20||@ Reds || 8–1 || deGrom (10–8) || Castillo (15–7) || — || Great American Ball Park || 20,576 || 80–73 |-style=background:#fbb |154|| September 21||@ Reds || 2–3 || Kuhnel (1–0) || Wilson (4–2) || Iglesias (34) || Great American Ball Park || 30,487 || 80–74 |-style=background:#bfb |155|| September 22||@ Reds || 6–3 || Brach (5–4) || Bauer (11–13) || Wilson (4) || Great American Ball Park || 21,335 || 81–74 |-style=background:#fbb |156|| September 23||Marlins || 4–8 || Smith (10–10) || Matz (10–10) || — || Citi Field|| 21,189 || 81–75 |-style=background:#bfb |157|| September 24||Marlins || 5–4 || Sewald (1–1) || Conley (2–10) || — || Citi Field|| 21,766 || 82–75 |-style=background:#bfb |158|| September 25||Marlins || 10–3 || deGrom (11–8) || Dugger (0–4) || — || Citi Field|| 21,471 || 83–75 |-style=background:#fbb |159|| September 26||Marlins || 2–4 || Brigham (3–2) || Wheeler (11–8) || Ureña (3) || Citi Field|| 21,729 || 83–76 |-style=background:#bfb |160|| September 27||Braves || 4–2 || Stroman (10–13) || Keuchel (8–8) || Lugo (6) || Citi Field|| 26,264 || 84–76 |-style=background:#bfb |161|| September 28||Braves || 3–0 || Matz (11–10) || Foltynewicz (8–6) || Díaz (26) || Citi Field|| 32,210 || 85–76 |-style=background:#bfb |162||