Brennan (Travis Burns) and their relationship eventually turned romantic. When Imogen decided to lose her virginity to Tyler, Kaplan explained that Imogen hoped it would help her move on from Daniel. She continued, "Her peers are all in serious relationships, so she feels it's time for her to be in one, too, Tyler is fun, there's nothing offensive about him, and he's probably the distraction she needs at this time." Imogen insisted that she no longer had feelings for Daniel, but her half-sister Paige Smith (Olympia Valance) had doubts and tried to make sure that she was taking the next step with Tyler for the right reasons. Kaplan felt for her character, as her feelings changed from "very definite and determined, to really floundering". While Imogen was in Tyler's bedroom, she realised that she could not go through with consummating their relationship and told Tyler that she still loved Daniel. Kaplan thought Imogen would have regretted having sex with Tyler and believed that backing out was the right thing to do. Kaplan hoped Imogen would focus on what makes her happy in the future. Departure and return On 4 April 2016, Daniel Kilkelly of Digital Spy speculated Kaplan had left Neighbours due to posts on her social media accounts that appeared to be "disguised farewells" to the show. A week later, Kilkelly and Sophie Dainty confirmed Imogen would be leaving the show, alongside Daniel (Tim Phillipps) on 26 April. Imogen receives a job offer from Naomi Canning in Los Angeles, and she and Daniel decide to move over there for a fresh start, following the deaths of Josh and Doug Willis (Terence Donovan). They are married shortly before their departure. On 25 February 2019, a writer for Soap World announced that Kaplan had reprised the role. Imogen reappeared on-screen during the episode airing on 22 March 2019. The character returns to run Toadfish Rebecchi's (Ryan Moloney) law firm, after he takes time away to grieve for his wife Sonya Rebecchi (Eve Morey) who recently died. Kaplan confirmed that Imogen was still married to Daniel. Imogen soon discovers that her younger sister Piper Willis (Mavournee Hazel) is in a casual relationship with their mother's former partner Leo Tanaka (Tim Kano), and urges her to tell Terese or she will. Imogen is later involved in the Finn Kelly (Rob Mills) redemption storyline when she becomes his lawyer. Mills said that Finn trusts