Though he interviewed for general manager positions with the Minnesota Wild and Florida Panthers, Feaster remained outside of the NHL for two years. He wrote a blog for The Hockey News during that time, and participated in chats on NHL radio. He was hired by the Calgary Flames to serve as assistant general manager to Darryl Sutter in July 2010. and became acting general manager of the Flames on December 28, 2010 upon Sutter's resignation. On May 18, 2011, Feaster became the permanent general manager of the Flames, removing the acting title. As general manager, he hired head coach Bob Hartley, a Stanley Cup, Calder Cup, and Swiss Championship winner. On December 12, 2013, Feaster was relieved as general manager of the Flames. Due to the 2004-2005 lockout, the Lightning gained an extra year with the Stanley Cup. Feaster used his time to take the Cup back to his hometown of Williamstown, PA, where the town declared it "Jay's Day" and had a fire truck parade for him and his family. He also traveled to Hilton Head Island, and took it to his home in Florida. His youngest son Kevin was baptized in the Cup at St. Stephens Catholic Church. Feaster's draft picks have included two-time Rocket Richard trophy winner Steven Stamkos(2008), Johnny Gaudreau(2011) 2014 Hobey Baker Award Winner, and Calder Finalist in 2015, and Sean Monahan(2013). On July 7, 2014, Feaster rejoined the Tampa Bay Lightning front office as their executive director of community hockey development. As executive director of hockey development, Feaster has worked with the Lightning sled hockey team, Everfi, Chase, hockey development in schools, and women's hockey programs. Some programs used to encourage women's hockey growth include girls hockey day, and clinics taught by Olympian Anne Schlepper. He also started the program, "Build the Thunder". In this program the Lightning would "Equip the Thunder" by giving 100,000 Lightning branded street hockey sticks and balls to fourth and fifth graders in Hillsborough, Pinellas, Pasco, Polk, and Manatee Counties. They visited 500 elementary schools, donated 500 complete sets of street hockey gear to those schools, and taught street hockey to more than 500 P.E. teachers. Lightning alumni and staff presented full-day street hockey clinics at each of those 500 schools. Feaster and his wife Anne have five children: Theresa, Bobby, Libby, Ryan, and Kevin. His eldest daughter Theresa is currently working for the 2014-2015 NCAA Men's Hockey National