200 Albums year-end chart. "MakeDamnSure" was number eight on the Alternative Songs chart, number 25 on the Digital Songs chart and number 36 on the UK Singles Chart. "Twenty-Twenty Surgery" was number 60 on the UK Singles Chart. "Liar (It Takes One to Know One)" was number 21 on the Alternative Songs chart and number 83 on the UK Singles Chart. By May 2009, the album had sold 674,000 copies. Accolades and legacy It was one of Alternative Press most-anticipated albums of the year, and topped Kerrang!s album-of-the-year poll. The music video for "MakeDamnSure" was nominated for an MTV2 Viewer's Choice award, which ultimately lost to "The Kill" (2006) by Thirty Seconds to Mars. TJ Horansky of Alternative Press wrote that with Louder Now, the group "started firing on all cylinders." Mascherino's "unique fluid and gruff vocals perfectly complement" Lazzara's "maniacal and effusive delivery," and Horansky called the vocals "much more natural" than Taking Back Sunday's previous albums. Fuse.tv's Jason Lipshutz called Louder Now his second-favorite Taking Back Sunday album. According to Lipshutz, it "was a mainstream mission statement, with ferocious guitar work and choruses aimed squarely at arenas." With moments of "true grace and contemplation," the album was "thrilling and complex." Rock Sound ranked it at number 55 on the list of best albums in their lifetime, stating that "nothing else in their back-catalogue boasts the huge songs, slick polish and, arguably, the heart of their major label debut." Louder Now has appeared on best-of emo album lists by The Daily Dot and Loudwire. Cleveland.com ranked "MakeDamnSure" at number 67 on their list of the top 100 pop-punk songs. Alternative Press ranked "MakeDamnSure" at number 54 on their list of the best 100 singles from the 2000s. The album was re-pressed on vinyl in June 2017, which charted at number 16 on the Vinyl Albums chart. Throughout 2019, the band performed Louder Now in its entirety for their 20th anniversary world tour. For cities in the US that had two shows back-to-back, the band would flip a coin to play either Louder Now or Where You Want to Be (2004) on the first night and the other album on the second night. To help promote the tour, a career-spanning compilation Twenty (2019) was released, which included "Liar (It Takes One to Know One)", "MakeDamnSure", "What's It Feel Like to Be a Ghost?" and "My Blue Heaven" from Louder Now.