the Ohio show. The police later stated that "the charge against Mettler stems from incidents that began December 15, 2007" and that "Rex displayed a pattern of activity over that time that reflected multiple attempts, if not numerous attempts, at stalking these females." Two years later, on June 17, 2010, Caesar Brantley was arrested on suspicion of stalking the duo. He pleaded not guilty. Aly claimed Brantley is an "obsessed fan" who is determined to marry her "no matter what" in filings for the restraining order. Another court hearing was scheduled on June 30. Religion Along with making music for the mainstream audience, Aly & AJ, who are both very open about their faith, were significant in the Christian music rock scene. "Never Far Behind" was only released on Christian rock radio. It went to No. 1 on Radio & Records (R&R) Christian CHR. The duo does not wish to be labeled as Christian music artists. In an interview with Blender magazine in June 2006, Aly & AJ said that their music comes from a Christian perspective. "We don't ever wanna preach or shove anything down people's throats, but we want our music to be inspiring." AJ added, "If we have a Muslim fan or an atheist fan, that's their thing – I'm gonna love them no matter what." They also expressed their disbelief in evolution. In 2018, Aly & AJ stated in an interview that they do believe in evolution. The pair have since rescinded their anti-evolution-theory stance in response to a fan on Twitter, writing: "Yes to evolution ... thank God for the glow up in not just body but mind". In 2010, Aly Michalka stated in an interview with Seventeen magazine, "My faith is definitely a big part of my life, but not part of my career. It is something that guides me. But I feel like when you make a declaration of your religion, people automatically go after you when that purity ring comes off. So I don't want to set myself up for that kind of judgment." Discography Studio albums Into the Rush (2005) Acoustic Hearts of Winter (2006) Insomniatic (2007) A Touch of the Beat Gets You Up on Your Feet Gets You Out and Then Into the Sun (2021) With Love From (2023) Extended plays Ten Years (2017) Sanctuary (2019) Tours Main Mini Mall Tour (2005) Living Room Tour (2006) Holiday Season Tour