Hartman Frankenstein Unfrozen Caveman Lawyer Chick Hazard, 1950s Private Investigator Russell Clark, host of "Sassy's Sassiest Boys" Beev Algar, father of Garth Algar on Wayne's World Eugene, host of Cooking with the Anal Retentive Chef Susan, the she-male in Sprockets Frank Sinatra Peter Graves Charlton Heston Donald Trump Jimmy Swaggart Jim Bakker James Stockdale Ronald Reagan (1986–89) Bill Clinton (1993–94) Ed McMahon Liberace Ted Kennedy Phil Donahue Jack Nicholson Burt Reynolds Pat Buchanan Jan Hooks Nancy Reagan Kathie Lee Gifford Hillary Clinton Tammy Faye Bakker Sinéad O'Connor Marge Keister Miss Connie Nancy Simmons, in Wayne's World Candy Sweeney, of The Sweeney Sisters Melanie Hutsell Jan Brady Tori Spelling Tonya Harding Di, of the "Delta Delta Delta" sorority J Victoria Jackson Roseanne Cyndi Lauper Nancy Maloney, a nightclub singer Colin Jost Pete Buttigieg K Chris Kattan Kyle DeMarco from The DeMarco Brothers Mr. Peepers Buddy Mills, a washed-up Vegas comedian in Rialto Grande Antonio Banderas from The How Do You Say? Ah, Yes, Show. Mango Gay Hitler Al Pacino Andy Dick Steve Irwin Paul Begala Paul Shaffer Ricky Martin David Lee Roth Azrael Abyss, co-host of Goth Talk Josh Zimmerman from The Zimmermans, where he and Cheri Oteri played an inappropriately sexual married couple Eddy Lewis, one of the Shopping at Home Network sports memorabilia guys Gollum (from The Lord of the Rings) Doug Butabi from The Roxbury Guys Suel Forrester (a.k.a. "the gibberish guy") Tim Kazurinsky Dr. Jack Badofsky Havnagootiim Vishnuuerheer Wayne Huevos Father Timothy Owens Worthington Clotman Husband in "I Married A Monkey" Mr. Landlord, in Mister Robinson's Neighborhood Laura Kightlinger Connie Chung Marcia Clark Taran Killam Michael Cera Gilbert Gottfried Pee-Wee Herman Chris Pine Finn Hudson "What Up with That?" announcer Brad Pitt Eminem Piers Morgan Ted Cruz Donald Trump Jebidiah Atkinson (Weekend Update) David Koechner Pat Buchanan Mike Ditka One of the Bill Brasky guys Gerald "T-Bones" Tibbons, a deranged redneck who takes on different odd jobs Gary Macdonald, the nervous joke-telling brother of Norm Macdonald Fagan of The British Fops Tom Taylor, neighbor who's always invited to Frank Henderson's (Will Ferrell) barbecues in the "Get Off The Shed!" sketches Gary Kroeger El Dorko Dwight MacNamara Donny Osmond Paul Shaffer Walter Mondale L Julia Louis-Dreyfus Marie Osmond Nina Blackwood Consuela, of "Chi Chi & Consuela" Yoko Ono Jon Lovitz Tonto Hanukkah Harry Annoying Man Evelyn Quince Harvey Fierstein Master Thespian Mephistopheles Michael Dukakis One of "The Girl