by AC/DC. Chart performance Personnel Metallica James Hetfield – vocals, rhythm guitar, piano Lars Ulrich – drums Kirk Hammett – lead guitar Robert Trujillo – bass Additional musicians David Campbell – orchestration References Metallica songs 1992 singles Heavy metal ballads 1998 singles 1990s ballads 1991 songs Songs written by James Hetfield Songs written by Lars Ulrich Songs written by Kirk Hammett Song recordings produced by Rick Rubin Song recordings produced by Bob Rock The Defiled songs Black-and-white music videos Elektra Records singles Number-one singles in Finland