Efren Ramirez as Juan Keir O'Donnell as Priest (Father Dino) Music "Starstrukk" by 3OH!3 featuring Katy Perry "Stupid Love Letter" by The Friday Night Boys "Heart Bling" by Sofi Bonde "Kickin' with You" by Jason Mraz "Something Beautiful" by Needtobreathe "How Far We've Come" by Matchbox Twenty "I Am Changing" by Mafia Bianca "Shine" by Laura Izibor "Honey, Let Me Sing You a Song" by Matt Hires "Hold On to Your Heart" by Tina Parol "Fox on the Run" by The Academy Is... "Pencil Full of Lead" by Paolo Nutini Songs from film, but not on soundtrack "Make You Feel My Love" by Adele "Ave Maria" by the City of Prague Philharmonic Orchestra "If You Can Afford Me" by Katy Perry "Cherry Pie" by Warrant The telephone call scene features the song "I Am Changing" by the Los Angeles band Mafia Bianca LLC, written and produced by Simone Sello and Steven Heinstein. Production Filming took place in Trafford, PA To promote the film, Don Johnson and Jon Heder co-hosted WWE's Monday Night RAW on January 18, 2010. The 3OH!3 music video for "Starstrukk Remix" featuring Katy Perry was set around motifs seen in and clips around When in Rome, and the song was on the film's soundtrack. The Friday Night Boys used clips from the movie in their music video for "Stupid Love Letter", which was featured on the movie soundtrack and in some of the previews for the movie. Popular references When Beth hands back the coins to Antonio, Lance, Gale, and Al, it is a parody of The Wizard of Oz, and Beth represents the Wizard giving each one something. Beth tells Gale that she will miss him "least of all". The line is a reversal of what Dorothy Gale says to the Scarecrow ("I'll miss you most of all") when she bids goodbye to him near the end of the film. The plot of the film is the reverse of the 1954 film Three Coins in the Fountain about women in Rome who throw coins in a fountain and find love. It is one of the films most shown by the Brazilian film program Sessão da Tarde since 2012, with its re-release airing between one and two months. Reception Critical response The film has received negative reviews from critics. Review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes reported that 17% of critics gave the film positive reviews based on 112 reviews