Child — Sydney, Little Lucie and Charles The Letter — Sydney Lament — Ernest Finale: I Can't Recall — Seamstress, Sydney and Men and Women of Paris √ Replaced with the Frank Wildhorn song "Never Say Goodbye" for the Brighton Concert. Song Changes "Prologue: The Shadows of the Night" changed throughout previews. What originally began by Dr. Manette singing about his letter ended with just him being shown being pulled off the stage by two guards. The opening night version featured only Lucie. "Resurrection Man" was cut after several previews, and was not featured for the opening night performance. "Let Her Be a Child" was edited to its original form during previews, no longer featuring Charles Darnay. Awards and nominations Drama Desk Award (2009) Outstanding Actor in a Musical (Nomination) - James Barbour Outstanding Orchestrations (Nomination) - Edward B. Kessel Outstanding Lighting Design in a Musical (Nomination) - Richard Pilbrow Outer Critics Circle Award (2009) Outstanding New Musical (Nomination) Outstanding Actor in a Musical (Nomination) - James Barbour Sarasota Magazine Theatre Awards (2008) Best Musical (WIN) Best Costume Design (WIN) - David Zinn Best Set Design (WIN) - Tony Walton Best Lighting Design (WIN) - Richard Pilbrow Best Music Direction (WIN) - Jerry Steichen Best Choreography (WIN) - Warren Carlyle Best Direction (WIN) - Michael Donald Edwards Best Supporting Actress (WIN) - Natalie Toro Best Supporting Actor (WIN) - Nick Wyman Best Actor (WIN-Tie) - James Barbour Best Actress (Nomination) - Jessica Rush Best Supporting Actor (Nomination) - Joe Cassidy Florida's Curtain Call Awards (2008) Best Musical (WIN) Best Featured Actor in a Musical - Nick Wyman (WIN) BroadwayWorld Fan-Choice Awards (2009) Best Featured Actress in a Musical (Nomination) - Natalie Toro (Runner-Up) Best Leading Actor in a Musical (Nomination) - James Barbour (Runner-Up) Best Leading Actress in a Musical (Nomination) - Brandi Burkhardt Best Lighting Design (Nomination) - Richard Pilbrow Best Costume Design (Nomination) - David Zinn (Runner-Up) Best Orchestrations (Nomination) - Edward B. Kessel Best Scenic Design (Nomination) - Tony Walton (Runner-Up) Production The hardest role to cast for the Broadway production was Lucie Manette. Brandi Burkhardt was persuaded by Barbour at a dinner outing to audition, which had not been cast. With many hopeful Lucies, Barbour had to arrange for Burkhardt to be seen in between auditions. Many of the shows stars stayed with the show for several years. Natalie Toro (Madame DeFarge), Nick Wyman (Barsad), Craig