(as a Klingon ship) in "Elaan of Troyius", in broadcast order it is first seen in this episode. Spock says at the start of the episode that "intelligence reports Romulans now using Klingon design." In the original broadcast episode all three ships were the D-7 design. Non-canon media The name of the Romulan commander and her fate are not revealed in the episode. At least two different explanations are given in Trek novels—The Price of the Phoenix and Vulcan's Heart. (In the early days of Trek writing, many novels contradicted each other, so the commander has had a number of names and fates.) The latest explanation is given in the novel Vulcan's Heart, by Josepha Sherman and Susan Shwartz, which gives her name as Liviana Charvanek. Apparently, sometime after the events of this episode, Charvanek was returned to Romulus and resumed her military career. D. C. Fontana co-wrote a sequel: Star Trek: Year Four—The Enterprise Experiment, a graphic novel published by IDW Publishing in 2008. This episode is referenced in the video game Star Trek: Tactical Assault. During a Federation mission the player's ship is equipped with the Romulan cloaking device stolen by Kirk and ordered to launch a sneak attack on a Klingon starbase. The Romulan commander and Subcommander Tal are central characters in the two-part series conclusion to Star Trek Continues. The part of the Romulan commander was played by Amy Rydell, daughter of Joanne Linville, who played the role in the original episode. The Romulan commander appears in the independently produced science fiction audio drama Starship Excelsior season 4 episode Tomorrow's Excelsior. In the episode it is revealed that the commander has received a promotion to Legate. The character was voiced by Joanne Linville who played the role in the original TOS episode. Reception In 2014, Gizmodo ranked "The Enterprise Incident" as the 48th best episode of Star Trek, out of the over 700 made by that time (including the spin-off series). In 2016, The Hollywood Reporter rated "The Enterprise Incident" the 33rd best television episode of all Star Trek franchise television prior to Star Trek: Discovery, including live-action and the animated series but not counting the movies. They note that this episode is the favorite of the director of the 2016 film Star Trek: Beyond, Justin Lin. In 2016, Newsweek ranked "The Enterprise Incident" as one of the best episodes of the original series. They note