DigiBio lab participated as consultants. Interviews at the time indicated study participants were satisfied with the way the study was being conducted. In the end, the authors reported in The FASEB Journal in 2006 that "Our team found no replicable effects from digital signals". INSERM The July 1989 edition of Nature reported that INSERM placed Benveniste on probation following a routine evaluation of his lab. Although INSERM found that his laboratory activities overall were exemplary, it expressed severe discomfort with his high dilution studies, and criticized him for "an insufficiently critical analysis of the results he reported, the cavalier character of the interpretations he made of them, and the abusive use of his scientific authority vis-à-vis his informing of the public". See also Experimental errors and frauds in physics Junk science Pathological science Protoscience Topics characterized as pseudoscience Scientific misconduct Notes References BBC Horizon (2002) Homeopathy: The Test, first broadcast 26 November 2002. Summary and transcript. Rebroadcast on ABC Catalyst in 2003.Homeopathy Part 1 Burridge, Jim (1992) "A Repeat of the 'Benveniste' Experiment: Statistical Analysis", Research Report 100, Department of Statistical Science, University College London, England. (early version of Hirst et al.) Chaplin, Martin (2000–2006) "Water Structure and Behavior London South Bank University Fottorino, Eric (1997) Le Monde, 21, 22 & 23 January 1997. Ives, John (2002) "Evaluating Unusual Claims and Devices Using a Team Approach: A Case Study", Subtle Energies & Energy Medicine, 13(1):39-59, based on Dr. Ives Keynote Address made at the Twelfth Annual ISSSEEM Conference The Co-Creation Process in Energy Medicine: A Synergy of the Sciences and the Healing Arts, 14–19 June 2002. Abstract, Full text Jonas, W. B. & J. Jacobs (1996) Healing with Homeopathy, Warner. Lignon, Yves (1999) "L’Homéopathie et la mémoire de l’eau", Les dossiers scientifiques de l'étrange, Chapter 21, Michel Lafon Publishing. . Full text in French Milgrom, Lionel (1999) "The memory of molecules", The Independent, 19 March. Full text Park, Bob (1999) "The Challenge: Homeopathy Via the Internet", What's New, 14 May. Full text (source 1)(2) Park, Bob (1997) "Alternative Medicine and the Laws of Physics", Skeptical Inquirer, 1 September 1997. Randi, James. Commentary. 26 January 2001 "a Nobel Laureate reneges" Commentary, January 26, 2001 - Computer problems, a Nobel Laureate reneges, more magnetic shoes, the metric system, and .... 5 September 2003 "Benveniste and Josephson on Abandoning Science" Commentary, September 5, 2003 — Benveniste and Josephson on Abandoning Science, Denmark Gets