Fay can identify the inmates from memory. Cora warns that she will arrest forty-nine people, normal or not, and Fay, helplessly, identifies all the Cookies, except Hapgood. She tells him the world needs people like him, and Hapgood can't turn himself in. He asks Fay to come with him, but she still can't bring herself to break free. They regretfully part ways. (“With So Little to Be Sure Of”) Word comes of a new miracle from the town beyond the valley, of a statue with a warm heart, and the townspeople, including Magruder and Cooley, rush off to see if it is real. Soon the town is all but deserted, and Cora is alone again. Again, Schub has the answer - they can turn the entire town into one big Cookie Jar. Cora realizes she and Schub are meant for each other, and they dance off together. As Fay resumes work, Detmold's real new assistant Jane Borden Osgood arrives, and Fay is horrified to realize that she is even more rigid and disbelieving than Fay herself, and the new nurse marches the Cookies off to the next town to disprove the new miracle. Horrified at seeing what she might become, Fay returns to the rock calling for Hapgood. When he doesn't answer, she tries to whistle - and succeeds in blowing a shrill, ugly whistle. Hapgood appears again, saying 'That's good enough for me.' As they embrace, the water begins flowing from the rock - a true miracle this time. (Finale) Notable casts Musical numbers (from the Broadway production) Act I Prelude Act I (instrumental) — Orchestra I'm Like the Bluebird — company Me and My Town — Cora Hoover Hooper and Boys Miracle Song — Cora, Treasurer Cooley, Townspeople, Tourists, and Pilgrims There Won't Be Trumpets — Fay Apple* Simple — J. Bowden Hapgood and Company Act II Prelude Act II (instrumental) — Orchestra A-1 March — Company Come Play Wiz Me — Fay, Hapgood, and Boys Anyone Can Whistle — Fay A Parade In Town — Cora Everybody Says Don't — Hapgood Don't Ballet (instrumental) — Orchestra Act III Prelude Act III (instrumental) — Orchestra I've Got You to Lean On — Cora, Comptroller Schub, Treasurer Cooley, Chief Magruder, and Boys See What It Gets You — Fay Anyone Can Whistle (Reprise) — Fay Cora's Chase (The Cookie Chase) — Company I'm Like the Bluebird (Reprise 1) —