18,347 || 19–16–4 || 42 || |- |- style="background:#fcc;" | 40 || January 2 || @ Calgary || 3–4 || || Lundqvist || Scotiabank Saddledome || 19,038 || 19–17–4 || 42 || |- style="background:#fcc;" | 41 || January 4 || @ Vancouver || 1–2 || || Georgiev || Rogers Arena || 18,871 || 19–18–4 || 42 || |- style="background:#cfc;" | 42 || January 7 || Colorado || 5–3 || || Shestyorkin || Madison Square Garden || 17,082 || 20–18–4 || 44 || |- style="background:#cfc;" | 43 || January 9 || New Jersey || 6–3 || || Shestyorkin || Madison Square Garden || 17,007 || 21–18–4 || 46 || |- style="background:#fcc;" | 44 || January 11 || @ St. Louis || 2–5 || || Lundqvist || Enterprise Center || 18,096 || 21–19–4 || 46 || |- style="background:#cfc;" | 45 || January 13 || NY Islanders || 6–2 || || Georgiev || Madison Square Garden || 17,403 || 22–19–4 || 48 || |- style="background:#cfc;" | 46 || January 16 || @ NY Islanders || 3–2 || || Georgiev || Nassau Coliseum || 13,917 || 23–19–4 || 50 || |- style="background:#fcc;" | 47 || January 19 || Columbus || 1–2 || || Shestyorkin || Madison Square Garden || 17,423 || 23–20–4 || 50 || |- style="background:#fcc;" | 48 || January 21 || NY Islanders || 2–4 || || Georgiev || Madison Square Garden || 17,276 || 23–21–4 || 50 || |- style="background:#cfc;" | 49 || January 31 || Detroit || 4–2 || || Shestyorkin || Madison Square Garden || 17,169 || 24–21–4 || 52 || |- |- style="background:#cfc;" | 50 || February 1 || @ Detroit || 1–0 || || Lundqvist || Little Caesars Arena || 19,515 || 25–21–4 || 54 || |- style="background:#fcc;" | 51 || February 3 || Dallas || 3–5 || || Lundqvist || Madison Square Garden || 15,779 || 25–22–4 || 54 || |- style="background:#cfc;" | 52 || February 5 || Toronto || 5–3 || || Shestyorkin || Madison Square Garden || 17,123 || 26–22–4 || 56 || |- style="background:#fcc;" | 53 || February 7 || Buffalo || 2–3 || || Georgiev || Madison Square Garden || 17,297 || 26–23–4 || 56 || |- style="background:#cfc;" | 54 || February 9 || Los Angeles || 4–1 || || Shestyorkin || Madison Square Garden || 17,237 || 27–23–4 || 58 || |- style="background:#cfc;" | 55 || February 11 || @ Winnipeg