that Basinski's technique can yield a wide range of results, something his career has proven beyond doubt but which his individual albums don't always reveal. And as irreconcilable as the concept of writing a eulogy based on loops might first appear (since loops are theoretically designed to never die), a deeper read and thorough listen suggests the opposite: Just like a lifetime, especially one as captivating as David Bowie's, Basinski's loops on A Shadow in Time make their way toward discernable endpoints—but not before suggesting they might go on forever." AllMusic critic Paul Simpon said, "As ever, Basinski is a master at suspending time, and the album seems to flow by faster than the clock indicates. When it does end, you wonder if you've been taken somewhere, or if you've been changed in some way. The only key to answering these questions is to dive back in." Accolades Track listing Personnel Credits adapted from A Shadow in Time album liner notes. William Basinski – primary artist Preston Wendel – engineering Denis Blackham – mastering Richard Chartier – design Deng Tai – photography References 2017 albums William Basinski albums Temporary Residence Limited albums Cultural depictions of David Bowie Drone music albums