Stephen Newton (1885–1890) : S. C. Newton (Middlesex) Henry Nixon (1873) : H. Nixon Frederick Norley (1865) : F. Norley (Kent) O T. C. O'Brien (1883–1905) : T. C. O'Brien (Middlesex) Edward O'Shaughnessy (1880–1883) : E. O'Shaughnessy (Kent) Cuthbert Ottaway (1876) : C. J. Ottaway (Middlesex) Hugh Owen (1885) : H. G. P. Owen (Essex) P Herbert Page (1886) : H. V. Page () Henry Palairet (1868–1869) : H. H. Palairet Elliot Parke (1879–1884) : E. A. Parke (South) John Parnham (1883–1889) : J. T. Parnham (United Eleven) Bernard Pauncefote (1871) : B. Pauncefote (Middlesex) Clement Pavey (1882) : C. S. Pavey Alfred Payne (1883–1884) : A. E. Payne (N/A) Thomas Pearce (1874–1876) : T. A. Pearce (South) Thomas Pearson (1873–1890) : T. S. Pearson (Middlesex) Francis Pelham, 5th Earl of Chichester (1868) : F. G. Pelham (Sussex) Francis Pember (1882–1885) : F. W. Pember (Hampshire) Frank Penn (1876–1881) : F. Penn (Kent) William Penn (1874) : W. Penn () John Pennycuick (1883) : J. Pennycuick () John Pentecost (1887) : J. H. Pentecost (Kent) Hylton Philipson (1889–1897) : H. Philipson () Jim Phillips (1888–1893) : J. Phillips (Middlesex, Victoria) Herbert Phipps (1865) : H. G. Phipps () Harry Pickett (1884–1898) : H. Pickett () Charles Pigg (1887–1901) : C. Pigg () Herbert Pigg (1893) : H. Pigg () Dick Pilling (1879–1883) : R. Pilling (Lancashire) John Platts (1870) : J. T. B. D. Platts () John Ponsonby-Fane (1869) : J. H. Ponsonby-Fane Dudley Pontifex (1883–1896) : D. D. Pontifex () Charles Pope (1894) : C. G. Pope (Cambridge University) Roland Pope (1889–1891) : R. J. Pope () Dick Pougher (1887–1902) : A. D. Pougher () Ernest Powell (1888–1895) : E. O. Powell () Walter Powys (1877–1879) : W. N. Powys (Hampshire) Walter Price (1868–1882) : W. Price (Nottinghamshire) Q Francis Quinton (1893–1895) : F. W. D. Quinton (Hampshire) R Francis Ramsay (1894) : M. F. Ramsay (Queensland) Frederick Randon (1874–1876) : F. Randon (Players of the North, North) Ranjitsinhji (1894–1912) : Ranjitsinhji () Harry Ravenhill (1882) : E. H. G. Ravenhill John Rawlin (1887–1909) : J. T. Rawlin () Walter Read (1890) : W. W. Read () Farrant Reed (1882) : H. F. Reed () Henry Renny-Tailyour (1875) : H. W. Renny-Tailyour (Kent) Alfred Renshaw (1871) : A. G. Renshaw Herbert Rhodes (1878–1883) : H. E. Rhodes (Yorkshire) William Richards (1866) : W. H. Richards Henry Richardson (1869–1870) :