the party (Annie's season) Other characters: Thomas Lennon as Lev Realness, a pop singer who sleeps with Haley Casey Wilson as Aunt Pam, Julie's aunt who gives her and Mark relationship counseling over the phone. Jeff Ross as himself Seth Rogen as Roger, a trainee medic Colton Dunn as Tim, the medic Paul Scheer as Robby Z, who returns as a judge for the dancing competition Carla Gallo as Tamara P, who returns as a judge for the dancing competition David Wain as Reg Durjmah, a "famed raincoat designer" who is the third judge for the dancing competition Story and episodes Depending on the season, the show either follows a man or a woman who is looking for the perfect mate from a pool of contestants, or has contestants living together in a mansion competing for a cash prize. Season one showcases fireman Mark Orlando (Ken Marino) as the bachelor. Season two of the series, which premiered in February 2013, stars June Diane Raphael reprising her role as season one contestant Julie, now the bachelorette given the chance to find the perfect man. Season three also premiered in 2013 and starred former contestants from seasons one and two competing for a $900 prize rather than for love (similar to Bachelor spin-off, Bachelor Pad). Season chronology The seasons of the show as listed do not match the internally referenced season chronology because of two fictitious seasons. Internally season one references the Joe Rutherford (Ben Stiller) season, and seasons two and three references the Annie (Abigail Spencer) season. Neither of these seasons was produced but occurred within the fiction of the show with events from those seasons being frequently mentioned during the course of various real episodes. Season three also announced a nonexistent season with superfan Hathwell Crisping. Burning Love with Joe Rutherford (nonexistent) 1. Burning Love with Mark Orlando Burning Love: Hot For Teacher (nonexistent) with Annie 2. Burning Love with Julie Gristlewhite 3. Burning Love: Burning Down The House Burning Love: A Fanty Tale (nonexistent) with Hathwell Granger Crisping Season 1 1 Bachelor Mark decided that this contestant was who he wanted to propose to. † The after the final hose ceremony episode. The contestant was eliminated when bachelorettes first arrived. The contestant was eliminated during hose ceremony. The contestant was eliminated by other contestants. The contestant received hose on group date. The contestant was eliminated in episode 6 on