as Henry, a contractor from Provo, UT and an all-around good guy Adam Brody as Max, a decent human being who happens to be Jewish Michael Cera as Wally, an intellectual who is a hopeless romantic Colin Hanks as Allison, the classy one Martin Starr as Leo, the grown up premature baby Ryan Hansen as Blaze, the bad boy Nick Kroll as Khris, a baby-sitter who recently had a bad breakup Kumail Nanjiani as Zakir, the token ethnic contestant Nick Thune as Teddy, the musical one Brandon Johnson as Trevor, one of the bonus contestants Other characters: Ben Stiller as Joe Rutherford, the bachelor from the show's (fictional) first season, now living in extreme poverty due to bad investments Christine Taylor as Symphony, Joe's wife Ken Marino as Mark Orlando, the previous season's bachelor Deanna Russo as Tamara G, who Mark has since broken up with Colton Dunn as Tim, the medic Abigail Spencer as Annie, bachelorette on the fictional "Burning Love: Hot for Teacher" season Paul Rudd as Annie's ex-fiancée Jessica St. Clair as Polly Katie Aselton as Idina Blimperson Rob Corddry as Lorenzo Blimperson Drew Droege as Cyrano Cruze-Shippe Rebecca Romijn as Katie Jensen Karp as Hot Karl Lindsey Kraft as Rebecca Janet Varney as Carly Season 3 cast Michael Ian Black as Bill Tundle, the host The contestants: June Diane Raphael as Julie, the "damaged goods" contestant (Mark's season, Julie's season) Joe Lo Truglio as Alex, the single dad who's emotional about not seeing his son (Julie's season) Natasha Leggero as Haley, the sex freak (Mark's season) Rob Huebel as Simon, a prince (Julie's season) Leslie Bibb as Bevarly, the southern party girl (Joe's season) Ryan Hansen as Blaze, the bad boy (Julie's season) Abigail Spencer as Annie, the "too perfect" contestant (Mark's season, Annie's season) Alex Anfanger as Noah, the virgin (Annie's season) Carly Craig as Felicia, the hot one (Joe's season) Kumail Nanjiani as Zakir, the bonus contestant (Julie's season) Helen Slayton-Hughes as Virginia, the twin of Agnes (from Mark's season), the older woman Armen Weitzman as Hathwell, the super fan Morgan Walsh as Vivian, a formerly pregnant contestant (Mark's season) Ken Marino as Mark, the sexy fireman (Mark's season) Christine Taylor as Symphony, the regretful winner (Joe's season) Beth Dover as Lexie, a contestant obsessed with Blaze (Mark's season) Janet Varney as Carly, the lesbian (Mark's season) Rob Delaney as Kirk, the life of