Women's Cup win at Chelsea in March 2011. Finding the standard of play in England higher than she had been used to, O'Gorman admitted to some disappointment with her first season total of four goals. Despite this, her hard working style had endeared her to the South Yorkshire club's supporters. At the end of the 2011 FA WSL season she returned to Peamount on loan ahead of the Irish club's 2011–12 UEFA Women's Champions League tie with Paris Saint-Germain. Although she was increasingly tired of living in a hotel, O'Gorman returned to Doncaster Rovers Belles for the 2012 FA WSL season. She was happy to be joined by compatriot Julie-Ann Russell who also signed. In September 2012 she marked her final game for the club with a 35-yard lobbed goal in The Belles' 3–2 defeat at title-winning Arsenal. Peamount United O'Gorman scored in Peamount's 6–3 WNL Cup final win over Castlebar Celtic in May 2013, to help the club retain the trophy. In October 2013, O'Gorman provided an assist for Stephanie Roche to score a celebrated goal in Peamount's win over Wexford Youths. Roche's goal eventually finished second in the FIFA Puskás Award, after it went viral on YouTube. "It was a great cross, wasn't it? It was all in the cross," O'Gorman later joked. In 2013–14 O'Gorman was named in the WNL Team of the Season, as Peamount were edged out in a close title race by Raheny United. UCD Waves Popular manager Eileen Gleeson left Peamount for UCD Waves in 2014, and O'Gorman was one of several Peamount players to follow Gleeson to her new club. When UCD Waves lost the 2014 FAI Women's Cup final 2–1 to Raheny United in extra-time, O'Gorman celebrated her equalising goal by revealing a t-shirt with stricken team-mate Chloe Mustaki's squad number 17 on it. She secured the 2014–15 Golden Boot when rival striker Katie McCabe's club Raheny United received a walkover in their final fixture at Cork City, who failed to muster a team. O'Gorman had already been named the WNL Player of the Season. In 2015–16, O'Gorman struck 17 goals to retain her Golden Boot title. She was also one of three nominees for Player of the Season, but lost out to UCD teammate Karen Duggan. UCD Waves were upset 1–0 by Cork City in the 2017 FAI Women's Cup final, but O'Gorman missed the occasion with a medial ligament