Bees and toxic chemicals
Bees can suffer serious effects from toxic chemicals in their environments. These include various synthetic chemicals, such as insecticides and fertilizers, as well as a variety of naturally occurring chemicals from plants, such as ethanol resulting from the fermentation of organic material. Bee intoxication can result from exposure to ethanol from fermented nectar, ripe fruits, and manmade and natural chemicals in the environment.
The effects of alcohol on bees are sufficiently similar to the effects of alcohol on humans that honey bees have been used as models of human ethanol intoxication. However, the metabolism of bees and humans is sufficiently different that bees can safely collect nectars from plants that contain compounds toxic to humans. The honey produced by bees from these toxic nectars can be poisonous if consumed by humans. Many humans have eaten toxic honey and become seriously ill as a result.
Natural processes can also introduce toxic substances into nontoxic honey produced from nontoxic nectar. Microorganisms in honey can convert some of the sugars in honey to the toxic compound ethanol. This process of ethanol fermentation is intentionally harnessed to produce the alcoholic beverage called mead from fermented honey.
 Effects of intoxication
The introduction of certain chemical substances—such as ethanol or pesticides or defensive toxic biochemicals produced by plants—to a bee’s environment can cause the bee to display abnormal or unusual behavior and disorientation. In sufficient quantities, such chemicals can poison and even kill the bee. The effects of alcohol on bees have long been recognized. For example, John Cumming described the effect in an 1864 publication on beekeeping.
When bees become intoxicated from ethanol consumption or poisoned with other chemicals, their balance is affected, and they are wobbly when they walk. Charles Abramson’s group at Oklahoma State University has put inebriated bees on running wheels, where they exhibit locomotion difficulties. They also put honey bees in shuttle-boxes that used a stimulus to encourage the bees to move, and found that they were less mobile as they became more intoxicated.
A temulent bee is more likely to stick out its tongue, or proboscis. Inebriated bees spend more time flying. If a bee is sufficiently intoxicated, it will just lie on its back and wiggle its legs. Inebriated bees typically have many more flying accidents as well. Some bees that consume ethanol become too inebriated to find their way back to the hive, and will die as a result. Bozic et al. (2006) found that alcohol consumption by honeybees disrupts foraging and social behaviors, and has some similar effects to poisoning with insecticides. Some bees become more aggressive after consuming alcohol.
Exposure to alcohol can have a prolonged effect on bees, lasting as long as 48 hours. This phenomenon is also observed in fruit flies and is connected to the neurotransmitter octopamine in fruit flies, which is also present in bees.
 Bees as ethanol inebriation models
In 1999, research by David Sandeman led to the realization that bee inebriation models are potentially valuable for understanding vertebrate and even human ethanol intoxication:
“Advances over the past three decades in our understanding of nervous systems are impressive and come from a multifaceted approach to the study of both vertebrate and invertebrate animals. An almost unexpected by-product of the parallel investigation of vertebrate and invertebrate nervous systems that is explored in this article is the emergent view of an intricate web of evolutionary homology and convergence exhibited in the structure and function of the nervous systems of these two large, paraphyletic groups of animals.”
The behavior of honey bees intoxicated by ethanol is being studied by scientists at The Ohio State University, Oklahoma State University, University of Ljubljana in Slovenia, and other sites as a potential model of the effects of alcohol on humans. At the Oklahoma State University, for example, Abramson’s research found significant correlations between the reactions of bees and other vertebrates to ethanol exposure:
“The purpose of this experiment was to test the feasibility of creating an animal model of ethanol consumption using social insects…. The experiments on consumption, locomotion, and learning suggest that exposure to ethanol influences behavior of honey bees similar to that observed in experiments with analogous vertebrates.”
It has thus been found that “the honey bee nervous system is similar to that of vertebrates”. These similarities are pronounced enough to even make it possible to derive information on the functioning of human brains from how bees react to certain chemicals. Julie Mustard, a researcher at Ohio State, explained that:
“On the molecular level, the brains of honey bees and humans work the same. Knowing how chronic alcohol use affects genes and proteins in the honey bee brain may help us eventually understand how alcoholism affects memory and behavior in humans, as well as the molecular basis of addiction.”
The evaluation of a bee model for ethanol inebration of vertebrates has just begun, but appears to be promising. The bees are fed ethanol solutions and their behavior observed. Researchers place the bees in tiny harnesses, and feed them varying concentrations of alcohol introduced into sugar solutions. Tests of locomotion, foraging, social interaction and aggressiveness are performed. Mustard has noted that “Alcohol affects bees and humans in similar ways—it impairs motor functioning along with learning and memory processing.” The interaction of bees with antabuse (disulfiram, a common medication administered as a treatment for alcoholism) has been tested as well.
 Bee exposure to other toxic and inebriating chemicals
 Synthetic chemicals
Bees can be severely and even fatally affected by pesticides, fertilizers, and other chemicals that man has introduced into the environment. They can appear inebriated and dizzy, and even die. This is serious because it has substantial economic consequences for agriculture.
This problem has been the object of growing concern. For example, researchers at the University of Hohenheim are studying how bees can be poisoned by exposure to seed disinfectants. In France, the Ministry of Agriculture commissioned an expert group, the Scientific and Technical Committee for the Multifactorial Study on Bees (CST), to study the intoxicating and sometimes fatal effects of chemicals used in agriculture on bees. Researchers at the Bee Research Institute and the Department of Food Chemistry and Analysis in the Czech Republic have pondered the intoxicating effects of various chemicals used to treat winter rapeseed crops. Romania suffered a severe case of widespread bee intoxication and extensive bee mortality from deltamethrin in 2002. The United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) even has published standards for testing chemicals for bee intoxication.
 Natural compounds
Bees and other Hymenoptera can also be substantially affected by natural compounds in the environment besides ethanol. For example, Dariusz L. Szlachetko of the Department of Plant Taxonomy and Nature Conservation, Gdańsk University observed wasps in Poland acting very sleepy and potentially inebriated after eating nectar of the North American orchid Neottica.
Detzel and Wink (1993) published an extensive review of 63 types of plant allelochemicals (alkaloids, terpenes, glycosides, etc.) and their effects on bees when consumed. It was found that 39 chemical compounds repelled bees (primarily alkaloids, coumarins, and saponins) and three terpene compounds attracted bees. They report that 17 out of 29 allelochemicals are toxic at some levels (especially alkaloids, saponins, cardiac glycosides and cyanogenic glycosides).
Various plants are known to have pollen which is toxic to honey bees, in some cases killing the adults (e.g., Zigadenus), in other cases creating a problem only when passed to the brood (e.g., Heliconia). Others plants which have toxic pollen are Spathodea campanulata and Ochroma lagopus. Both the pollen and nectar of the California Buckeye (Aesculus californica) are toxic to honeybees, and it is thought that other members of the Buckeye family are also.
 Bee inebriation in pollination
Some plants reportedly rely on using intoxicating chemicals to produce inebriated bees, and use this inebriation as part of their reproductive strategy. One plant that some claim uses this mechanism is the South American bucket orchid (Coryanthes sp.), an epiphyte. The bucket orchid attracts male euglossine bees with its scent, derived from a variety of aromatic compounds. The bees store these compounds in specialized spongy pouches inside their swollen hind legs, as they appear to use the scent (or derivatives thereof) in order to attract females.
However, the flower is constructed in such a way as to make the surface almost impossible to cling to, with smooth, downward-pointing hairs; the bees commonly slip and fall into the fluid in the bucket, and the only navigable route out is a narrow, constricting passage that either glues a “pollinium” (a pollen sack) on their body (if the flower has not yet been visited) or removes any pollinium that is there (if the flower has already been visited). The passageway constricts after a bee has entered, and holds it there for a few minutes, allowing the glue to dry and securing the pollinium. It has been suggested that this process involves “inebriation” of the bees, but this effect has never been confirmed.
In this way, the bucket orchid passes its pollen from flower to flower. This mechanism is almost but not quite species specific, as it is possible for a few closely related bees to pollinate any given species of orchid, as long as the bees are similar in size and are attracted by the same compounds.
Van der Pijl and Dodson (1966) observed that bees of the genera Eulaema and Xylocopa exhibit symptoms of inebriation after consuming nectar from the orchids Sobralia violacea and Sobralia rosea. The Gongora horichiana orchid was suspected by Lanau (1992) of producing pheromones like a female euglossine bee and even somewhat resembles a female euglossine bee shape, using these characteristics to spread its pollen:
“A hapless male bee, blind drunk with the flower’s overpowering pheromones, might well mistake a toadstool for a suitable mate, but the flower has made at least a modest attempt at recreating a beelike gestalt.”
However, this seems unlikely, given that no one has ever documented that female euglossines produce pheromones; male euglossines produce pheromones using the chemicals they collect from orchids, and these pheromones attract females, rather than the converse, as Cullina (2004) suggests.
 Toxic honey
Some substances which are toxic to humans have no effect on bees. If bees obtain their nectar from certain flowers, the resulting honey can be psychoactive, or even toxic to humans, but innocuous to bees and their larvae.
There have been famous episodes of inebriation of humans from consuming toxic honey throughout history. For example, honey produced from nectar of Rhododendron ponticum (also known as Azalea pontica) contains alkaloids that are poisonous to humans but do not harm bees. Xenophon, Aristotle, Strabo, Pliny the Elder, and Columella all document the results of eating this “maddening” honey. Honey from these plants poisoned Roman troops in the first century BC under Pompey the Great when they were attacking the Heptakometes in Turkey. The soldiers were delirious and vomiting after eating the toxic honey. The Romans were easily defeated.
Honey produced from the nectar of Andromeda flowers contains grayanotoxins which can paralyze the limbs, and eventually the diaphragm and result in death. Honey obtained from Kalmia latifolia, the calico bush, mountain laurel or spoon-wood of the northern United States, and allied species such as sheep laurel (Kalmia angustifolia) can produce sickness or even death. The nectar of the “wharangi bush“, Melicope ternata, in New Zealand also produces toxic honey, and this has been fatal. The dangers of toxic honey were also well-known among the Pre-Columbian residents of the Yucatán Peninsula, though this was honey produced by stingless bees, not by honey bees which are not native to the Americas. Bee nectar collection from Datura plants in Mexico and Hungary, belladonna flowers, henbane (Hyoscamus niger) plants from Hungary, Serjania lethalis from Brazil, Gelsemium sempervirens from the American Southwest, and Coriaria arborea from New Zealand can all result in toxic honey, as can honey made from other toxic plants such as oleander. Narcotic opium honey has also been reported from honey made in areas where opium poppy cultivation is widespread.
 Fermented honey
Honey that is not produced from the nectar of toxic plants[clarification needed] can also ferment to produce ethanol, which is toxic. For example, B. D. Kettlewellh (1945) describes finding an intoxicated bird, incapable of normal flight, that had been consuming honey that had fermented in the sun in Pretoria, Transvaal, South Africa.
Sometimes honey is fermented intentionally to produce mead, a fermented alcoholic beverage made of honey, water, and yeast (called “meadhing”). Mead is also known as “honey wine“.
 See also
- Colony collapse disorder
- Pesticide toxicity to bees
- Diseases of the honey bee
- Pollinator decline
- Bee (mythology)
- List of honey plants
 Notes and references
- ^Of course, other creatures are not immune to the effects of alcohol:
- Many of us have noticed that bees or yellow jackets cannot fly well after having drunk the juice of overripe fruits or berries; bears have been seen to stagger and fall down after eating fermented honey; and birds often crash or fly haphazardly while intoxicated on ethanol that occurs naturally as free-floating microorganisms convert vegetable carbohydrates to [alcohol] (Warren K. Bickel, Richard J. DeGrandpre (1996). Drug Policy and Human Nature: Psychological Perspectives On The Prevention, Management, and Treatment of Illicit Drug Abuse
- ^ Fruit flies and other insects also exhibit symptoms of ethanol intoxication (Heberlein, Ulrike; Wolf, Fred W.; Rothenfluh, Adrian; Guarnieri, Douglas J. (2004). “Molecular Genetic Analysis of Ethanol Intoxication in Drosophila melanogaster“
- ^ Latest Buzz in Research: Intoxicated Honey bees may clue Scientists into Drunken Human Behavior, The Ohio State Research News, Research Communications, Columbus OH, October 23, 2004.
- ^ John Cumming (1864). Bee-keeping, by ‘The Times’ bee-master
- ^ a b c d e Charles I. Abramson, Sherril M. Stone, Richard A. Ortez, Alessandra Luccardi, Kyla L. Vann, Kate D. Hanig, Justin Rice (August 2000). “The Development of an Ethanol Model Using Social Insects I: Behavior Studies of the Honey Bee (Apis mellifera L.): Neurobiological, Psychosocial, and Developmental Correlates of Drinking”
. Alcoholism: Clinical & Experimental Research 24 (8): 1153–66.
- ^ Bozic J., Abramson C.I., Bedencic M. (2006). “Reduced ability of ethanol drinkers for social communication in honeybees (Apis mellifera carnica Poll.)”
- ^ Abramson CI, Place AJ, Aquino IS, Fernandez A (June 2004). “Development of an ethanol model using social insects: IV. Influence of ethanol on the aggression of Africanized honey bees (Apis mellifera L.)”. Psychol Rep 94 (3 Pt 2): 1107–15. PMID 15362379
- ^ Happy Hour Bees , Mythology and Mead
, Carolyn Smagalski, BellaOnline, The Voice of Women, 2007 describes a prolonged effect from ethanol consumption by honey bees as similar to a “hangover”.
- ^ Ulrike Heberlein’s group at University of California, San Francisco has used fruit flies as models of human inebriation and even identified genes that seem to be responsible for alcohol tolerance accumulation (believed to be associated with veisalgia, or hangover), and produced genetically engineered strains that do not develop alcohol tolerance
Moore MS, DeZazzo J, Luk AY, Tully T, Singh CM, Heberlein U (June 1998). “Ethanol intoxication in Drosophila: Genetic and pharmacological evidence for regulation by the cAMP signaling pathway”
Tecott LH, Heberlein U (December 1998). “Y do we drink?”
, Ruth Williams, Naked Scientist; “‘Hangover gene’ is key to alcohol tolerance”
, Gaia Vince, NewScientist.com news service, 22 August 2005). Accessed July 17, 2009.
- ^ Degen J, Gewecke M, Roeder T (June 2000). “Octopamine receptors in the honey bee and locust nervous system: pharmacological similarities between homologous receptors of distantly related species”
- ^ Sandeman D (August 1999). “Homology and convergence in vertebrate and invertebrate nervous systems”
- ^ a b c d Intoxicated Honey Bees May Clue Scientists Into Drunken Human Behavior
, Science Daily, October 25, 2004
- ^ Entomology Postdoctoral researcher Dr. Geraldine Wright, Ohio State University
- ^ a b Entomology Postdoctoral researcher Dr. Julie Mustard, Ohio State University
- ^ Abramson CI, Fellows GW, Browne BL, Lawson A, Ortiz RA (April 2003). “Development of an ethanol model using social insects: II. Effect of Antabuse on consumatory responses and learned behavior of the honey bee (Apis mellifera L.)”. Psychol Rep 92 (2): 365–78. doi:10.2466/PR0.92.2.365-378
- ^ “Honey bee intoxication caused by seed disinfectants”
, Dr.sc.agr. Klaus Wallner, University of Hohenheim. Accessed on July 17, 2009.
- ^ Recent Issues Related to Bee Troubles in France
, J.N. Tasei, report to International Apis Health Assessment Committee (IAHAC), Bologna, Italy, May 6, 2004. This report included the results of a study of the toxic effects on bees of the seed dressings imidacloprid and fipronil.
- ^ František Kamler, Dalibor Titěra, Jiřina Piškulová, Jana Hajšlová, Kateřina Maštovská (2003). “Intoxication of honeybees on chemical treated winter rape: problem of its verification”
- ^ Daniela Nica, Elisabeta Bianu, Gabriela Chioveanu (2004). “A case of acute intoxication with deltamethrin in bee colonies in Romania”
(PDF). Apiacta 39: 71–7.
- ^ Ecological Effects Test Guidelines OPPTS 850.3030: Honey Bee Toxicity of Residues on Foliage
, EPA 712–C–96–148 April 1996.
- ^ Nelis A. Cingel (2001). An atlas of orchid pollination: America, Africa, Asia and Australia
- ^ Detzel, Andreas; Wink, Michael (March 1993). “Attraction, deterrence or intoxication of bees (Apis mellifera) by plant allelochemicals”
- ^ “School Native Plant Gardens and Nature Areas”
. California Native Plant Society. Archived from the original
on August 17, 2007. Retrieved 2007-04-26.
- ^ Dodson C.H., Frymire G.P. (1961). “Natural pollination of orchids”. Mo. Bot. Gard. Bull. 49 (9): 133–152.
- ^ Pierre Jolivet (1998). Interrelationship Between Insects and Plants
. CRC Press. p. 192. ISBN 1574440527. “The first hymenopteran to visit has difficulties coping with the rostrellum but the later ones to arrive easily escape, soaked, drunk, and often having completed their pollinating function.”
- ^ bumblebee.org article on Hymenoptera
- ^ William C. Agosta (2001). Thieves, Deceivers, and Killers: tales of chemistry in nature
- ^ Pollination by Euglossine Bees
, Robert L. Dressler, Evolution, Vol. 22, No. 1 (Mar., 1968), pp. 202-210 doi:10.2307/2406664
- ^ Nelis A. Cingel (2001). An atlas of orchid pollination: America, Africa, Asia and Australia
- ^ Leendert Van der Pijl, Calaway H. Dodson (1966). Orchid Flowers Their Pollination and Evolution. University of Miami Press. ISBN 0870240692.
- ^ Lunau, Klaus (June 1992). “Evolutionary aspects of perfume collection in male euglossine bees (Hymenoptera) and of nest deception in bee-pollinated flowers”
. speculated that the chemicals produced by the bucket orchid mimic bee pheromones.
- ^ a b William Cullina (2004). Understanding Orchids : An Uncomplicated Guide to Growing the World’s Most Exotic Plants. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. p. 180. ISBN 0-618-26326-8.
- ^ Mayor, Adrienne (November-December 1995). “Mad Honey [toxic honey in history]“. Archaeology 48 (6).
- ^ a b c “Grayanotoxin”
. Foodborne Pathogenic Microorganisms and Natural Toxins Handbook. US FDA. 2001. Retrieved 2007-05-01.
- ^ Kelhoffer, James A. (2005). “John the Baptist’s “Wild Honey” and “Honey” in Antiquity”
. Greek, Roman, and Byzantine Studies 45: 59–73.
- ^ G. P. Georghiou (1980). “Ancient Beekeeping”. In Root, A.I.. The ABC and XYZ of Bee Culture. Medina, Ohio: A.I. Root Company. pp. 17–21.
- ^ J. T. Ambrose (1972). Bees and Warfare: Gleanings in Bee Culture. pp. 343–6.
- ^ Yaacov Lensky (1997). Bee Products: Properties, Applications, and Apitherapy
- ^ Consumption of the leaves of Kalmia can be fatal to cattle and grouse. (Neltje Blanchan (1900). Nature’s Garden: An Aid to Our Knowledge of Our Wild Flowers and Their Insect Visitors
. Garden City Pub. Co.)
- ^ D. Espina-Prez, G.S. Ordetx-Ros (1983). Flora Apcola Tropical. Cartago, Costa Rica: Editorial Tecnolgico de Costa Rica. p. 35.
- ^ Ott, J. (1998). “The Delphic Bee: Bees and Toxic Honeys as Pointers to Psychoactive and Other Medicinal Plants”. Economic Botany 52 (3): 260–6. doi:10.1007/BF02862143
- ^ Reid, M. “Background on toxic honey”
. New Zealand Food Safety Authority. Accessed on July 17, 2009.
- ^ Crane, E. 1975. Honey: a Comprehensive Survey, Bee Research Association. William Heinemann Ltd., London; Espina-Prez, D. and G.S. Ordetx-Ros. 1983. Flora Apcola Tropical, Editorial Tecnolgico de Costa Rica, Cartago, Costa Rica.
- ^ Oleander
. MedLine Plus. February 17, 2009. Accessed on July 17, 2009.
- ^ Alistair McAlpine (2002). Adventures of a Collector
- ^ Kettlewellh, B.D. (February 1945). “A Story of Nature’s Debauch”. The Entomologist 88 (1101): 45–7.
- ^ The history of mead may go back more than 8,000 years. A reference in the Vedas, the sacred book of the Hindus, cites honey as a sacred item as far back as the 8th century BCE. Aristotle described honey beverages. The word for “drunk” in classical Greek even is translated as “honey-intoxicated.” (Karl Kerenyi (1976). Dionysus: Archetypal Image of Indestructible Life. Princeton University Press. ISBN 0-691-09863-8.)
 Further reading
How to Reduce Bee Poisoning from Pesticides PNW 591, A Pacific Northwest Extension Publication, Washington, Oregon, Idaho, Copyright 2006, Oregon State University. Revision of the WSU 1999 version of the same publication.
- How to Reduce Bee Poisoning from Pesticides
, D.F. Mayer, C.A. Johansen, C.R. Baird, PNW518, A Pacific Northwest Extension Publication, Washington, Oregon, Idaho, Copyright 1999 Washington State University. Includes an extensive list of toxic chemicals such as pesticides that affect bees.
- Protecting Honeybees From Pesticides, Dean K. McBride, 1997
- Honey Bees and Pesticides
- Protecting Honey Bees From Pesticides
, University of Florida Institute of Food and Agricultural Sciences Extension, Malcolm T. Sanford, April 1993