Statisticians at the University of St Andrews have debunked a study by Swiss agrochemical company Syngenta that concluded there was only a low risk to honey bees from widely used neonicotinoid pesticides.
The Syngenta study was on the effects of the neonic thiamethoxam on honey bees in the field.
New research conducted at the Scottish university’s Center for Research into Ecological and Environmental Modelling (CREEM) shows even large and important effects could have been missed because the Syngenta study was statistically too small.
The research by Dr. Robert Schick, Prof. Jeremy Greenwood and Prof. Steve Buckland is published today in the journal Environmental Sciences Europe.
The Syngenta study involved two experiments –:an oilseed rape experiment conducted at two locations and a maize experiment at three locations.
At each location, the experiments used pairs of fields – in one field the crop was treated with thiamethoxam at levels normally used by farmers, in the other field the crop was untreated.
The Syngenta study concluded that because the experiments involved so little replication (two cases for oilseed rape and three for maize) a formal analysis of the data “would lack the power to detect anything other than very large treatment effects, and it is clear from a simple inspection of the results that no large treatment effects were present. Therefore, a formal statistical analysis was not conducted because this would be potentially misleading”.
The St Andrews team says this is fundamentally wrong, because formal statistical analysis is only potentially misleading if the wrong method is used and because the mere inspection of the results is always potentially misleading because it is an entirely subjective procedure.
“In order to reach valid conclusions about the results of an experiment such as this, one needs not just to estimate the effect of the treatment but also to measure the precision of the estimate,” Greenwood says. “That is what we have done, using standard statistical techniques.
“What we found was that the estimates of the treatment effects were so imprecise that one could not tell whether the effects were either too small to pose a problem or, in contrast, so large as to be of serious concern.
“In effect, the experiments were on such a small scale that little useful could be concluded from them.”
To be up to date with the latest in the apiculture industry to may visit our beekeeping latest news. On the other hand if you’re new to beekeeping and would like to begin professional beekeeping today get a copy of our beekeeping for beginners ebook.
Beekeeping can be a full-time profession or an easy hobby. Nevertheless, more often than not, what started as a hobby would turn into a profession. But you cannot just decide and tell yourself that you will start to do beekeeping. You need to have sufficient knowledge and comprehension on the area that you’re going to enter before beginning on any avocation or profession. Then it is about time to indulge yourself in your line of interest, if you have been putting off your interest in beekeeping for quite a while. Bee farming may not appear difficult; learning the fundamental beekeeping lessons can allow you to get away to a great beginning.
What does a beekeeper have to understand?
On beekeeping to begin at the right foot first, you should have interest that is complete. You’ve got to spend time taking care of your own colonies of bees. You should also have agreed to share your home space with the bees. There are potential dangers in beekeeping that can damage you but your family as well. Your focus isn’t just to build an income by selling honey; a great beekeeper should have a keen interest and passion in raising bees.
An apiarist should know the right location for the beehives. The place must have adequate sources of nectar for the bees to get. If you decide to put your beehives you need certainly to make sure that beekeeping is allowed in your town. There are several places limited to beekeeping; you should get permission relating to this.
Beekeepers must know whether beekeeping supplies are available in the region where the beehives are situated. When you have to go to a local beekeeping shop you may never understand; it’s best that a nearby beekeeping shop is not inaccessible.
Protective gear and equipment are also important for beekeepers to understand. This will minimize the chances of being stung by your bees. Understand the right kind of suit to select to keep you from any possible risk in beekeeping.
In case you are not able to harvest honey from your bees all the beekeeping efforts would be ineffective. A beekeeper should know the procedures in gathering the honey from your comb; beeswax is also part of the yields in beekeeping.