Step 3. Assess whether the supported claims warrant publication in the journal ○ Several questions can be used to guide the evaluation of the impact of the claims: i) Do the claims differ from prevailing thinking? ii) Do the claims clarify an existing ambiguity? iii) Do the claims enable new avenues for exploration? ○ For those claims that have partial support, one can provide a differential assessment based on the possible outcomes of the proposed additional experiments. ○ Assess whether the scholarly presentation is appropriate for publication.