In our previous discussion about water and ice, we considered two main q-Gaussian components, characterized by two different q-parameters. We proposed the two parameters as linked to two different local environments of OH-bonds (the q-parameters of q-Gaussians can be related to the correlation time of stochastic Kubo modelling of fluctuations). As stressed by Martin Chaplin in his discussion about the vibrational spectra, the "water structuring is now firmly established … as best interpreted using a two-state water mixture" (Chaplin mentioning . Of course, the two states have a differente local environment for their oscillators.