<prompt> Human: 11816 I paid cash for a car from a guy on craigslist. He and his uncle showed up and they both have dealership licenses. I bought a 2007 Toyota Scion Tc 5 speed manual with 151k miles. 3900 cash.I have: Motor Vehicle Title Reassignment Supplement form. Transferring ownership from Malba Auto Sales in Florida to Chase Auto sales in Danbury CT.Certificate of title for the car. Which has a different name on it. From NJ.Supplemental Assignment of ownership andor Bill of sale. Transferring from Chase Auto Sales to me. I filled out a DTF -802 form for NY DMV and a Vehicle RegistrationTitle Application to switch the plates from a car in my wifes name to this car.The DMV says that because Mabel Auto Sales is blacklisted I cant register the car at all in NY. They gave me a complaint form to fill out and told me to try to get my money back from Chase Auto Sales. What am I to do? This is all crazy to me. I spoke to the guy and he said he has never had that problem before and that he wants the paperwork so he can re-transfer the title to my wife and get the plates for me. Also to give him the money for the taxes.Im not trying to screwed anymore than I already am. Please help me!Edit: Taken care of. Answer is in the comments. Thank you everyone!  <response>: I am NOT an expert, but would it help at all to see if they would just meet you at the DMV to get this straightened out? Also, there may be sub-Reddits related to buying and selling used cars where you may be able to get better answers. 