 Nyorai kupfuurira kweiyi ndima - Pana December 10, 1864, Milligan, Bowles, naHorsey vakawanwa vane mhaka pamhosva dzose uye vakatongerwa kuturika pana May 19, 1865. Humphreys akawanwa ane mhaka ndokutongerwa kushanda zvakaoma kwasara kwehondo, asi mutongo wake wakazochinjwa, uchibvumira kusunungurwa kwake. Kuedza kwakaitwa kuti Milligan, Bowles, naHorsey varegererwe, chisarudzo chacho chichipfuudzwa kuMutungamiri Andrew Johnson pashure pokuurayiwa kwaLincoln. Musi waMay 16 kuurayiwa kwaMilligan naBowles kwakamiswa kusvika pana June 2, uye mutongo waHorsey wakashandurwa kuva mutongo weupenyu hwose. Purezidhendi Johnson akabvumidza kuchinjwa kwemitongo yaMilligan naBowles kuva mutongo weupenyu hwose musi waMay 30, 1865. Vasungwa vacho vakachinjirwa kubva kuIndianapolis kuenda kujeri rehurumende muColumbus, Ohio. 