 Butt akaenderera mberi nekuunganidza kukudzwa kwakawanda kuUnited, sezvo kirabhu yakavhara kutonga kwavo kwema1990 nekukunda kunoshamisa uye kwakasarudzika muna 1999 naButt achitamba mutambo wese weChampions League Finalnokuda kwokumiswa basa kwaRoy Keane, uye mamwe mazita akawanda mumakore kusvikira muna 2001. Pakazosvika nguva yekubva kwake kuOld Trafford, Butt akanga awana menduru nhanhatu dzePremier League, menduru nhatu dzeFA Cup uye menduru yeChampions League. Akanga awanawo menduru yeFA Cup runners-up muna 1995. 