 Nyora kupfuurira kweiyi ndima - Mwaka wa2004 wakanga wakasiana nokuda kwaGarner. Mushure mekunge Houston Astros yatanga zvishoma nezvishoma pasi pemaneja wenguva iyoyo Jimy Williams, Garner akaunzwa pakati pemwaka kuti atsive Williams uye akatungamira Astros kuenda kuNational League Wild Card berth, pakupedzisira achirasikirwa mumitambo minomwe kuSt. Louis muNational League Championship Series. Chikwata chakaona kumwe kutanga kunononoka muna 2005 asi chakaita kumhanya zvakare mukupera kwemwaka uye chakadzoka kuzokunda imwe National League Wild Card. Panguva ino, Houston yaizokunda St. Louis Cardinals muNational League Championship Seriesmumitambo mitanhatu ndokukunda mukombe chete kuti vakundwe neChicago White Sox muWorld Series. 