 Nyorai mberi kweiyi ndima - Reynolds akanyoresa paXavier University muna 2012 apedza kudzidza paBrewster Academy. Achitongwa asina kukodzera, akagara kunze kwemwaka wa2012-13 uye akaita XU yake yekutanga panguva yemushandirapamwe wa2013-14. Akamiswa basa kwenguva isingazivikanwi muna January 2014. Maererano nehuwandu, gore rake rakanaka raive muna 2014-15, mwaka wake wechipiri, apo Reynolds akaenzana 9.9 mapoinzi uye 6.1 rebounds makwikwi. Iye akagamuchira BIG EAST Championship All-Tournament Team kukudzwa gore iroro. Muna Kurume 2015, kunyunyuta kwakaiswa pamusoro pake nemumwe mudzidzi, Reynolds akaburitswa munyaya iyi muna Chivabvu. Mushure mekunge avhareji 9.6 mapoinzi uye 6.5 rebounds mutambo mumwaka wa 2015-16, Reynolds akazivisa kuti 2016 NBA Draft, asi haana kunyorwa. 