 Evaristo akahwina mumutambo wekutanga wakatambirwa kuCamp Nou munaGunyana 1957, uye akazova mutambi wekutanga kuhwina hat-trick pasi. Mumwaka wakatevera, akarova zvibodzwa zvitatu achipesana nemakwikwi eEuropean Real Madrid munzira yekuenda kuBarcelona yekutanga La Liga zita mumakore matanhatu. Musi wa 23 Mbudzi 1960, mumutambo wechipiri weEuropean Cup tie neReal Madrid kuCamp Nou, panguva iyo mutongi weChirungu akarasa zvibodzwa zvina zvakasiyana zveReal Madrid, Evaristo akarova musoro wekudonha nemaminetsi masere ekupedzisira, izvo zvakabvisa vavengi veBarcelona kubva mumakwikwi kekutanga uye vakapedza tariro yavo yechitanhatu chinyorwa chinoteedzana. Evaristo akarova zvibodzwa zvitanhatu panguva yeBarcelona kuenda kumagumo ekutanga eEuropean Cup, iyo vakarasikirwa ne3 × 2 kuBenfica paWankdorf Stadium muBern, ikozvino inoyeukwa se Square-Posts Final nekuda kwemutambo unonzi chikonzero chekuti chimiro chemasuo chakachinjwa. 