 Nyora kupfuurira kweiyi ndima - Collins akasaina kondirakiti yemakore mana neAston Villa yemari isina kuziviswa musi wa1 Gunyana 2009, zuva rekupedzisira remahwindo ekuchinjisa. Pakutanga kwake muligi yeVilla, musi wa13 Gunyana, akavabatsira kuchengetedza pepa rakachena muChipiri Guta Derby vachipesana neBirmingham City. Chibodzwa chake chekutanga chekirabhu yaive yekukunda kurwisa Chelsea mukukunda 2-1, kwaakatumidzwa zita rekuti Man of the Match. Collins akatamba maminitsi makumi mapfumbamwe akazara eLigi Cup FinalpaWembley musi wa 28 Kukadzi 2010, iyo yakaona Aston Villa ichirohwa 12 neManchester United. Collins akatambawo mutambo wakazara apo Villa yakadzokera kuWembley musi wa10 Kubvumbi 2010, mukukundwa ne0 3 neChelsea muFA Cup semi-fainari. Muna Kurume 2011, maneja Gérard Houllier akabhadhara Collins nemumwe wake wepakati-kumashure Richard Dunne mibairo yemavhiki maviri mushure meizvo zvakaziviswa se nharo yekudhakwa nevashandi vekirabhu panguva yechikwata-chisungo chiitiko. 