 Colantuono akatungamira kubudirira kweAtalanta kudzokera kunhandare yepamusoro panguva ya2011-12 Serie A mwaka, zvichikonzera kugadzikana kwe12th-nzvimbo yekupedzisa, kunyangwe kirabhu ichitanga mwaka iine matanho matanhatu ekubviswa nekuda kwekubatanidzwa kwayo mu2011-12 nhabvu yenhabvu yeItaly. Kuwedzerwa kwemapoinzi maviri kwakatevera pamberi pegore ra2012 13 Serie A; zvisinei, Colantuono achiri kukwanisa kutungamira Atalanta kuchengetedzeka nekupedza nzvimbo yegumi neshanu. Kuramba nemutungamiri wavo we 2013 14 Serie Amumushandirapamwe, Coulantuono akachengetedza nzvimbo yechi11 uye mamwe maitiro anonakidza, kusanganisira kukunda kwevakwikwidzi vemunharaunda Internazionale uye A.C. Milan. Pamberi pekutanga kwegore ra2014-15 Serie A mwaka, Coulantuono akazvipira ramangwana rake kuAtalanta, zvisinei, mwaka hauna kufamba zvakanaka uye mushure mekutenderera kwakashata kwechimiro akadzingwa musi wa4 Kurume 2015 uye akatsiviwa naEdy Reja, achisiya Atalanta chete 3 mapoinzi pamusoro penzvimbo yekudzikira. Akatora nzvimbo yemurairidzi mukuru nokukurumidza pashure paUdinese. 