 Nyorai kupfuurira kweiyi ndima - Muna 1972, Scherman akaunganidza 73 rekodhi uye 3.64 ERA ine 12 inochengetedza mumitambo 57, kusanganisira mitatu semutambi anotanga. Scherman akatamba muMutambo 2 we1972 American League Championship Series, kurasikirwa na 5-0. Akarova Reggie Jackson pasi kaviri nepfuti mukati meplate, uye mutambo wakazoputika mukurwa apo Lerrin LaGrow akarova Bert Campaneris nepfuti mumutambo mumwe chete. Vamwe vakapa mhaka kuderedza kwaSherman kwaJackson nokuda kwokuparira kurwa. Scherman akakanda inning imwe chete muALCS uye haana kubvumira kuwana run. Scherman akakunda mubairo we King Tiger kubva kuvateveri veDetroit muna 1971 na1972. 