 Nyora kupfuurira kweiyi ndima - Muna November 1999, The Courier-Journal munyori Judith Egerton akafanotaura kuti rwiyo rwacho rwaizodanwa nokuda kweAcademy Award. Muna 2000, When She Loved Me akasarudzwa kuti awane mubairo weOscar weBest Original Song pa72nd Academy Awards, achiva wechi13 Newman akasarudzwa muchikamu ichi, uye rwiyo rwake rwechipiri rweOscar-rwakasarudzwa kubva ku Toy Story firimu nhepfenyuro, mushure mekunge awana kusarudzwa kwekutanga kwemipiro yake yemimhanzi ku Toy Story soundtrack. Kusarudzwa kwenziyo kwaifungidzirwa kuti kwakanga kusingawanzoitiki panguva iyoyo nokuti, kusiyana nemafirimu akawanda emifananidzo akanga awana mazita akanzi Best Original Song pamberi payo, Toy Story 2 haisi mimhanzi. Vatsoropodzi vazhinjisa vaikarira kuti Newman pakupedzisira aizohwina mubairo wake wokutanga weAcademy nokuda kweWhen She Loved Me. Magazini yeLGBT The Advocate yakaseka kuti rwiyo rwacho rwaiva rwiyo rwokutanga rworudo rwevasikana-vasikana rwakasarudzwa kuOscar, vachitaura nezvehukama huri pakati paJessie naEmily. Pakupedzisira, rwiyo rwakarasikirwa naPhil Collins Uchave uri mumoyo mangu kubva muDisneys animated firimu Tarzan 1999. When She Loved Me yakanga yakasarudzwa nokuda kweGolden Globe Award yeBest Original Song, iyo yakarasikirwawo ne Uchave Mumwoyo Wangu. When She Loved Me akaenderera mberi kuhwina mubairo weGrammy weRwiyo Rakanakisa Rwakanyorwa Mufirimu, Terevhizheni kana Imwe Vhidhiyo yeVhidhiyo pa43rd Grammy Awardsmuna 2001. Rwiyo rwacho rwakakundawo mubairo weGolden Satellite weBest Original Song pa4th Golden Satellite Awards muna 2000. GamesRadar yakaisa When She Loved Me panzvimbo yechitanhatu yePixar yakanakisisa. 