 Nyorai kuenderera mberi kweiyi ndima - Akatanga basa rake kumusha Worksop asati aenda kuBarnsley musi wa21 Chikumi 1909. Akatamba mumakwikwi maviri eFA Cup ayo Barnsley akasvika muna 1910 na1912. Muna 1910 FA Cup, Bartrop akarova chinangwa chinoshamisa mukukunda kwekota-fainari 10 pamusoro peQueens Park Rangers. Mumutambo wekupedzisira, Barnsley yakarasikirwa neNewcastle 2-0 mushure mekunge vakwikwidza 1-1. Mumakwikwi ekupedzisira ekombe ra1912 akazoitwa zvekare asi Barnsley yakakunda, ichikunda West Bromwich Albion 10 munguva yekuwedzera, mushure mekunge vakwikwidzana 00 mumutambo wekutanga. Mapepanhau akawanda, kubatanidza Manchester Guardian, akarumbidza kutamba kwake mukudzokorora. 