 Athersmith yakaita basa rakakosha mumativi eVilla anokunda mukombe muna 1894, 1896, 1897, 1899 na1900 pamwe nekusvika kumatatu ekupedzisira eFA Cup, achipedzisa parutivi rwakarasika muna 1892 asati awana menduru dzevakundi muna 1895uye wokupedzisira wokukunda kaviri wemwaka wa1896-97. Akanga ariwo nhengo yechikwata icho chaive vanyajambwa vekuponda hofori mu1899-1900 FA Cup mumaoko eMillwall Athletic. 