 Kutevera kupondwa kwaJune 12, 1994 kwaimbova mudzimai waO.J. Simpson Nicole Brown Simpson neshamwari yake Ron Goldman, Schiller akabatana naSimpson, uyo akanga ari mutorongo achimirira kutongwa kwake kwenyaya yeropa kwakakurumbirapanguva iyoyo, pabhuku rainzi Ndinoda Kukuudzai, iro rakanga raiswa pachena seyaiva nyeredzi yenhabvu ichipindura mibvunzo kubva kuvateveri pamusoro poupenyu hwake nechiitiko chacho. Kutevera kusunungurwa kwaSimpson pamhosva dzokuponda, Schiller uye aimbova mutori wenhau yemagazini yeTime Jim Willwerth vakanyora American Tragedy: Iyo Uncensored Nhau yeSimpson Defense, inoonekwa seimwe yemabhuku akanakisa nezvenyaya iyi. Dan Whitcomb, uyo akafukidza kutongwa kunoshamisa kweReuters, akashanda naSchiller somutsvakurudzi pabhuku racho. 