 Jay akaita mutambo wake wekutanga mukuru weCardinals mu2010, mushure mekurova.301, aine 34 home runs HR,.803 pa-base pamwe ne slugging percentage OBP, uye 61 yakabiwa mabhesi SB, mumitambo ye409 yevadiki. Mutambi wepakati anotanga makirabhu mana anoteedzana eNational League Championship Series NLCS -anokodzera makirabhu seKardinal 201114, aive shasha yeWorld Series muna 2011, sezvo maCardinal akakunda maTexas Rangers. Pakati pa2011 na2013, Jay akaisa rekodhi risina kukanganisa reNational League NL pakati pevashandi vemunda pamitambo 245. Muna 2012, akapedza chegumi muNL mune zvese zviri zviviri zvekurova uye pa-base muzana OBP. 